Peter Beaumont in
Jerusalem
Thursday June 13, 2002
The Guardian
Marwan Barghouti, the Palestinian politician who is credited with
being the key organiser of the intifada, is being "systematically
tortured" while in Israeli detention, according to his lawyers.
Supporters of Mr Barghouti - who the Israelis say masterminded the
deaths of dozens of Israelis - say he has suffered so-called "position
torture" and sleep deprivation since being arrested by Israeli
soldiers on April 15.
He has yet to be charged with any crime.
Mr Barghouti, the leader of Tanzim, the armed wing of Yasser
Arafat's Fatah movement, is said to be the leader of the militants who
have carried out shootings and bombings.
The Israelis also accuse him of being the founder of the Al-Aqsa
Martyrs' Brigade, which has claimed responsibility for a large number
of suicide bombings.
Mr Barghouti, who was jailed by Israel for six years in the 80s for
membership of a Fatah faction, denies the allegations and says he is a
political leader resisting Israeli occupation.
An Israeli government official emphatically denied claims of
torture, saying that Barghouti is being "treated with kid gloves"
because of his high profile. He added that if he was not sleeping,it
was "because his conscience was keeping him awake".
Israeli government sources said yesterday that any decision on
whether to prosecute Mr Barghouti would have to be made by cabinet,
despite the fact that the constitution separates the executive and the
legislature. Israel is likely to request that his period of detention
be extended when he appears in court next week.
The allegations of mistreatment were repeated yesterday by Khalid
Shkirat, a lawyer and the director general of LAW, a Palestinian human
rights group advising Bargh outi. He said that Mr Barghouti told him
he had been subjected to shabeh, a form of constraining torture, where
the hands and legs are shackled to a small chair angled to slant
forward, so that the victim cannot sit in a stable position.
Mr Shkirat said yesterday that Mr Barghouti had complained of pains
in his back and hands caused by shabeh and had said he was being kept
awake for periods of 20 hours at a time.
He has also alleged that his interrogators have made threats to
kill him and his son, who is also in an Israeli jail.
"I have seen Marwan six times since his arrest," Mr Shkirat said
yesterday. "He has lost an awful lot of weight and looks exhausted. He
is still wearing the same track suit that he was given on his arrest.
"He has asked for underwear but has not been given any. He also
told me he was allowed a two-minute shower once a week.'
Asked about the confession of involvement in terrorism that Israeli
papers say Mr Barghouti made, Mr Shkirat said: "Marwan knew nothing
about these claims. He says he has made no confession. He believes
these claims were being made to undermine the confidence of
Palestinians in their leaders.'
The use of sleep-deprivation, shabeh and violent shaking of hooded
prisoners during interrogations was outlawed by the Israeli high court
in 1999. Following that ruling, which makes those using torture liable
to imprisonment and evidence obtained in such a way inadmissible,
claims of torture declined. They have risen again since the intifada
began in 2000.
"After the court ruling in 1999 there were virtually no reports of
torture," Hannah Freidman, executive director of the Jerusalem-based
Public Committee Against Torture in Israel, said. "When the intifada
started in October 2000 it seemed to increase rapidly.
"We have collected many affidavits alleging torture and I have
spoken to two of Marwan Barghouti's lawyers who have both reported how
he has been interrogated for 20 hours at a time, shackled in a small
chair."
Mr Barghouti was arrested by the Israeli army while leaving a safe
house in Ramallah where he had been hiding during Operation Defensive
Shield. He is currently being held at the Petah Tikva detention
centre.
Allegations of Mr Barghouti's mistreatment while under
interrogation by the Shin Bet security service follow claims by Israel
that Barghouti was the key link between the Palestinian Authority
chairman, Yasser Arafat, and terrorists involved in attacks on
Israelis.
Israel has released documents that it claims prove that Mr
Barghouti channelled funds between Mr Arafat and wanted "terrorists".
Mr Barghouti has been spoken of as a potential successor to Yasser
Arafat. Since his arrest polls suggest his support among Palestinians
has trebled, despite claims of a confession. He has emerged as the
leading co-ordinator of day-to-day insurrection in the West Bank.